Heat’s Performance A Big Flop?
Now, that all the hoopla and drama of the NBA season is over I’d thought I’d share some of my thoughts regarding the Miami Heat and their season. I should start off by saying that I am a fan of the Chicago Bulls, and that I usually adopt a couple of other teams each season due to their game and character. Early on this year I adopted the Dallas Mavericks as my B team based on the fact that I felt that Dirk was under appreciated and that they played beautiful team basketball.
In terms of the Heat I’ve always liked Wade and James but never had a strong appreciation of Bosh’s game. I, like many others, viewed the triad as being a tad immature, especially James, in how they used the media to preen before the cameras like rock stars and divas. I love the game of basketball and was a tad concerned that their immediate success could have a negative impact on the integrity of the sport.
As the year progressed my fears regarding the negative impact the Heat and the trio in particular could have on the longer term direction of professional basketball only got worse. Wade and James in particular seemed to become more immature and whinier as the year progressed. They seemed to view themselves as basketball royalty and were incensed any time a foul was called on them, or when they felt they were fouled (pretty much any time they shot and missed) and it wasn’t called.
James and Wade’s willingness to present their case or mildly lecture or educate every official over the most trivial of events seemed to become routine. I often wondered how their coach was able to impart any strategy during time outs as it seemed like James or Wade used every time out and stoppage of play as an opportunity to talk and work on the refs.
In previous posts I’ve outlined my concerns regarding commissioner Stern and his tendency to view the game as a product rather than a professional sport. The drama surrounding the Heat increased interest in the NBA world wide and even if not totally thrilled with some of their antics, I’m sure Stern was very pleased with the boost these lovable heroes/villains gave to revenues.
My biggest concern going into the playoffs was that the semi-spoken rule that the NBA as commercial product needs their super stars on the floor would once again dominate the quality of the officiating. Stern’s fining Pat Riley for resting Magic, Worthy and (Abdul-Jabbar?) when he coached the Lakers is a fine example of the priority of product over sport. For those not old enough to remember, Riley sat his stars for a meaningless game towards the end of the season to help them them rest for the playoffs. Stern fined Riley thousands of dollars because he felt that ticket holders were entitled to see the stars they paid money to see, and had no concern about player fatigue or performance. Maybe he felt that the preferential calls by the refs would more than make up for any fatigue or minor injury that could hamper the stars performances.
As I said I was very concerned that James and Wade would not be allowed to foul out of the game no matter what they did. Combine that with the fact that Wade and James never believe they commit a foul and my imagination went wild with scenes of Shaq in his hey day pummeling and barreling over opponents on his quest to make undefended dunks to the glee of giddy TV play-by-play announcers.
Yet, I must admit the reality of the situation was not as bad as I had imagined. In fact I almost felt like I owed Stern an apology for my perception, almost.
A few disconcerting patters emerged in the games I saw the Heat play in the playoffs. My worst fears materialized early in games where there were ample opportunities to call offensive and defensive fouls on James and Wade. Most of these calls weren’t made and when the whistle blew the refs usually searched for a teammate in the area to assign the foul to.
In the early playoff series James and Wade often maximized on their special treatment and cajoled and scolded the refs into giving them even more preferential treatment. Yet, even in the early rounds I was pleased to see more balanced and realistic calls during the last half of the fourth quarters. The Heat and their stars who looked increasingly angry and befuddled at not getting their typical end of game assistance.
In the finals in particular there were actually times in which James and Wade were fouled and the call was not made. In addition, the fact that the lack of earlier foul calls on Wade and James made it possible for the refs to call the most flagrant rule violations in the final minutes with no fear of fouling out the stars. This new twist to officiating seemed to confuse and frustrate Wade and James who never quite adapted to their being treated as mere mortals during crunch time.
What most surprised me in the finals was how frequently James and Wade did not continue to force the issue and go to the rim and fall to the floor in an attempts to get to the free throw line. I’m not quite sure the refs would have been able to stand up to that kind of pressure. The lack of theatrics during the final phase of the game was in sharp contrast with the behavior of the dynamic duo during the earlier sections of the games.
I was amazed at how often James and Wade in particular would flop to the ground anytime the least bit of contact occurred both offensively and defensively (hence the title of this post). Though this behavior is at least indirectly fostered by the refs with how frequently the acting results in a favorable call, it still is jaw droppingly pathetic from a personal integrity point of view. Do Wade and James think that they really need such stunts to win the game? Are they so pampered or delusional that they don’t see how that behavior tarnished the respect of discerning fans and players especially from a historical perspective
I, for one, would truly like to see how good Wade and James are without all the prima donna preening and behavior. Even though Bosh himself does high drama, he only resorts to such theater a few times a game and in general conducts himself in a manner respecting the integrity of the sport. In the playoffs I was very impressed with most aspects of Bosh’s game and did not see him as being “too soft” as many have labeled him. Sure he’s not the most physical of players and could be a more consistent force on the boards but he did not wilt under the pressure of the playoffs and was probably the person most responsible for their getting past the Bulls.
When all is said and done it appears that the Heat became too dependent on their theatrics and on beneficial calls. When the calls they were accustomed to getting began to desert them (in the final few minutes of games) they became tentative and bewildered to such a degree that they no longer forced the issue or even had the awareness to flop to the floor when on defense. Without theater they were not able to see themselves as super heroes appearing out of the colorful mist of strobe lights, but rather became merely a couple of the most talented athletes of this generation. Which should be enough, but this time it wasn’t.
It would be nice if this was used by Wade and James as a learning experience, and inspired them to rededicate them to the substance of the game. Yet, at this point it seems more likely that they will choose to cast themselves as victims and instead have them become more resolved to whine, act and scold their way to an NBA championship, which I have little doubt they will be able to do.
I’ve always respected Wade as an athlete and as a person, likewise for James, though at times I thought he was a little too pampered and had some growing up to do. Yet, the two together and the hype have appeared to bring out the very worst in their personalities. The immaturity they have displayed and then denied or explained away is saddening.
The theatrics on the basketball court has been pushed up another notch by the Heat. Though flopping has been used to encourage a whistle throughout the NBA, the Heat use this device as often as most teams do the pick and roll. Since refs are less likely to call a charging foul if the defender remains upright it only makes sense to fall when an opposing player slams into you. Yet, even with that in mind, the Heat are going to the ground even at the hint of contact especially Wade, who almost goes to the floor every time his shot is defended.
Flopping isn’t the only disconcerting trend. The amount of traveling (seldom called) increased dramatically this year especially in the playoffs. Once again the Heat led the league in this department. Players are taking the ball and running to the basket for a slam dunk without taking a single dribble or stopping their dribble and taking three of four steps before slamming the ball home. Maybe the refs and commissioner feel the extra steps make for a more spectacular dunk and, therefore, should be allowed to add to the entertainment value of the product (game). Yet, in the playoffs the expectation to dribble or follow the rules regarding traveling became almost non-existent.
On a number of occasions I heard announcers squeal in excitement how a player “split the defense” with an “amazing” move to get to the basket. In reality the defenders met the player at the legal limit of their advance and the player illegally ran (walked) past them and dunked the ball. Years of training and habit of defenders caused them to make this error over and over again, as superstars electrified crowds by walking great distances to the hoop without dribbling the ball.
Another illegal trend in basketball is in the use of the “first step” and the “pivot foot”. I was again appalled with the success players were allowed to have starting a drive without dribbling, or doing numerous feints with both feet to get a defender off balance before taking the ball to the basket. My assumption is that these illegal behaviors are tolerated because they allow for more thunderous dunks and “amazing” moves. Players must feel a personal and social pressure to be inventive and increasingly sensational and this is the shortest route to instant athleticism.
Despite these short comings the Dallas Mavericks were a breath or fresh air. They played pretty basketball in an old school sense. They passed, shot the ball well, and made their free throws. They truly were a beautiful team to watch from an execution point of view both offensively and defensively. The won the series, but I’m sure they lost in terms of the highlight reel.
Now I would like to answer the original question of this post. Was the Heat a flop?
The short answer is no. When all is said and done, they were a couple of plays or calls from being NBA champions. It is foolish to say that they couldn’t have beaten the Mavericks or that if we were to start the series again today that the result would be the same. If Lebron missed the shots in the Chicago series that he did in the finals, then the Bulls would have been in the championship. Its been awhile since I’ve seen a team so dominant that it was inevitable that they win it all. Sometimes we do see teams which we cannot imagine winning a title. Yet, this year there were at least six reams which had a legitimate chance to win the title.
The Heat was definitely capable of winning the title, and if they had you would be reading countless articles how they would be destined to win five or six more. I’m glad that the team playing the best team basketball one the title. From a fundamental and execution standpoint they were most deserving.
The NBA is at a crossroads they could continue their path on to better entertainment value and product development. If this is the route they take we should expect a further lenience and freedom allotted the athletes to make even more spectacular and unbelievable moves befitting super heroes. The Heat, at least for a few years, can fulfill the role of the greatest show on hardwood.
Yet, maybe the commissioner isn’t too old to appreciate the true beauty of basketball and is capable of giving the fans a little credit for loving the game and not just the product. Maybe he can take advantage of the opportunities offered by the batch of new talent in the NBA who seem humble and dedicated to team basketball rather than hype and adoration. Maybe he can replace allegiance of players to their posse and agents with a dedication to their team and city.
If he looks around he can see much to build on. You have players such as Rose and Durant who seem to have humility and appreciation of their opportunities. You have young teams such as the Grizzlies, Bulls, Thunder and Nuggets which seem to respect their teammates and coaches and could further the original team spirit of the sport. Despite all the hype and egoism the last few championships have gone to teams who functioned as teams such as the Spurs, Celtics and Mavericks. Each of these teams despite their individual talents and experience fiercely dedicated to executing the plays and systems of their coaches.
I did not include the Lakers to the above list of teams because, despite the managerial talents of Phil Jackson, the Lakers at times seemed to be more like the Heat than the Mavericks and it is possible that the Heat will become the eastern version of showtime.
I will end this post by stating that I fear that David Stern will take the wrong road. His dictatorial approach seems to mimic that of his egotistic players. From a distance the actions of Stern have always seemed to be a little grandiose and self-serving. He seems to be more like Dwayne Wade and Lebron James than Derrick Rose or Kevin Durant.
From what I’ve seen Mr. Stern would be better fitted to be the manager of the Harlem Globetrotters or professional wrestling where his entertainment packaging priorities would be less damaging. This is not said out of hate of Mr. Stern but as a lover of the sport of basketball. Its hard enough for professional sports to survive the dangers of gambling, organized crime, agent and corporate greed. With these obstacles we do not need a commissioner whose major concern is marketing and public relations.
Jim Guido